Lower Keys dining guide

Summerland Key restaurants

A laid-back island stop with a small airfield, marina services and local food. Use cuisine and dining-style filters to turn 4 food-and-drink listings into a practical shortlist.

Search locally

All restaurants on Summerland Key

Source-linked listings with cuisine and dining-experience filters.

Traveling with a dog?Show listings with a publicly reported dog-friendly policy.

Next step

What are you hungry for?

Choose a cuisine to narrow the restaurants on this island.

How do you want to dine?

Use practical details such as waterfront seating, takeout and late-night food.

3 places found

Verified source

Summerland Key · Restaurants & Nightlife

A Slice of Paradise

American & Keys ClassicsItalian & Pizza
DiningPizzaQuick bites

Long-running Summerland Key pizza stop offering classic and specialty hand-tossed pies, hot subs, wings, salads and calzones for an easy casual meal or takeout along the Overseas Highway.

24458 Overseas Hwy, Summerland Key, FL 33042

Verified source

Summerland Key · Restaurants & Nightlife

Galley Grill

SeafoodAmerican & Keys ClassicsBreakfast & Brunch
DiningBreakfastLunch

Family-run Summerland Key restaurant serving locals and travelers since the mid-1980s with a large breakfast menu, sandwiches, burgers, seafood specials and homestyle lunch favorites.

24862 Overseas Hwy, Summerland Key, FL 33042

Verified source

Summerland Key · Restaurants & Nightlife

Tonio’s Seafood Shack & Tiki Bar

SeafoodAmerican & Keys ClassicsBars & Nightlife
DiningSeafoodWaterfront restaurants

Waterfront Summerland Key seafood restaurant and 50-seat outdoor tiki bar serving fresh local seafood, tropical cocktails and beer with live entertainment and rotating specials.

25163 Overseas Hwy, Summerland Key, FL 33042